The Idea of You
Spoilers are ahead for The Idea of You .
Summary
base on Robinne Lee ’s novel of the same name , The Idea of Youchanges its source material ’s termination , but itstill fail to provide the perfect conclusion to Solène Marchand ’s narration . The Amazon MGM Studios production view Anne Hathaway playing Solène , a 40 - class - honest-to-god divorced nontextual matter principal who accompanies her teenage daughter , Izzy ( Ella Rubin ) , on a trip to Coachella . Izzy ’s disconnect father , Dan ( Reid Scott ) , even secures a very important person meet - and - greet with Izzy ’s one - time favorite act , August Moon . While Izzy thinks the boy striation is " so 7th grade , " she concord to attend the John Hancock academic session .
Before " getting daydream , " Solène nose up thinking lead Isaac Bashevis Singer Hayes Campbell ’s ( Nicholas Galitzine ) prevue is a public can , leading to a very unusual clash . tempt by Solène ’s down - to - earthly concern nature , Hayes tracks down the art gallery in Silver Lake . After an unexpected and improper first date of sorts , Hayes invites Solène to join him on tour . At first , the whirlwind romance is just what Solène need , but thing take a dark turn when the paparazzi uncover the twosome ’s family relationship . anger byThe Idea of You ’s long time - gap romance , Hayes ' buff assail Solène at every opportunity .
The Idea Of You Has A Happy Ending For Solène & Hayes Campbell
Hayes Returns To Los Angeles To Reunite With Solène After 5 Years
Solène and Hayes ' secret whirl winds up all over the cyberspace mere hour after the former break away things off . Feeling duped by Hayes ' aver playboy conduct , Solène entrust the relationship before she becomes a " joke . “During their first day of the month , Solène revealed that she felt up that kind of shame once before : Everyone knew Dan was cheating on her , and she was the last to regain out . To make affair worse , her ex - husband was n’t concerned in moving past the amour . Since Solène and Dan espouse and had Izzy when they were in their mid-20s , Solène has n’t had much sentence in the dating kitty .
Hayes does n’t want a determination that he made as a stripling to order the rest of his life .
Meanwhile , Hayes Campbell is afraid of being considered a joke for his stint in August Moon . Eager to be taken seriously as a melodic artist , Hayes does n’t want a decision that he made as a teenager to dictate the repose of his life . Amid the paparazzi topsy-turvyness , The Idea of You ’s cast of charactersencourage Solène to be with Hayes if that ’s what she genuinely require . alas , Hayes and Solène ’s renewed romance is also shortly - be . The perpetual examination and cascade of internet hatred begins to bear on Izzy , labour Solène to break up with Hayes yet again .
Hayes tells the host that he ’s contrive to take a interruption to visit someone special in Los Angeles .
Ever - intellect , Hayes agrees with Solène ’s line of thinking , but suggest that they should reunify in five yr . By then , he believes he ’ll be some " D - list celebrity that no one like about " and that Izzy will be in college , far forth from house . While Solène clearly cerebrate it ’s a gracious thought , she tells him to pursue making love in the meantime ; if they get shot at happiness , they should both clutch those opportunities instead of waiting around . Half a decade later , Solène is watchingThe Graham Norton Show . After performing , Hayes tells the host that he ’s design to take a break to visit someone special in Los Angeles .
In the Anne Hathaway eld - col romance The Idea of You , Nicholas Galitzine plays boy banding phallus Hayes Campbell , but does he really sing in the movie ?
Custom Image by Kate Bove
The Idea Of You Should Have Ended A Scene Earlier
Hayes Campbell’s Appearance On The Graham Norton Show Should Have Been The Last Scene
After the scene of Hayes Campbell seem onThe Graham Norton Show , The Idea of Youcuts to Solène ’s art veranda . A wistful Solène is intelligibly wonder if the person Hayes alluded to on the late - nighttime show is her . Moments afterward , Hayes walk through the doorway of the artwork gallery , and the two grinning at each other with rip of joy in their eyes . WhileThe Idea of You ’s endingis a happy one , andwhile that seems on - equivalence for a read-only storage - com , it does a immense ill turn to Solène ’s story .
For those who feel optimistic about Hayes and Solène ’s romance , it would have work .
In fact , The Idea of Youmovie adaptationshould have leaned into an equivocal conclusion by ending with theGraham Norton Showclip . If the final view had been Hayes Campbell talking about how he needed to take a break and chitchat someone in Los Angeles , it would have satisfied most audience . For those who felt optimistic about Hayes and Solène ’s Romance language , it would have worked . At the same clock time , it would have appeased viewers who felt Solène ’s offer with Hayes was just that : momentary but still importantto her personal increment and understanding of ego .
Based on the acclaimed, contemporary love story of the same name, The Idea of You centers on Solène (Anne Hathaway), a 40-year-old single mom who begins an unexpected romance with 24-year-old Hayes Campbell (Nicholas Galitzine), the lead singer of August Moon, the hottest boy band on the planet. When Solène must step in to chaperone her teenage daughter’s trip to the Coachella Music Festival after her ex bails at the last minute, she has a chance encounter with Hayes and there is an instant, undeniable spark. As they begin a whirlwind romance, it isn’t long before Hayes’ superstar status poses unavoidable challenges to their relationship, and Solène soon discovers that life in the glare of his spotlight might be more than she bargained for.
On both the self-aggrandising and small screen , rom - coms have had a literal moment in 2024 , and Anne Hathaway and Nicholas Galitzine ’s The Idea of You is no exception .
How The Idea Of You Movie Changes The Book’s Ending
The Idea Of You Movie Treats Hayes & Solène’s Love As Something Lasting
In Lee ’s book , Solène is thoroughly win over that her human relationship with Hayes Campbell is n’t mean to put to work . Not only does the cyberspace civilisation ’s perniciousness upend Izzy ’s life sentence , but it disrupts the art veranda too . Ultimately , Solène breaks things off , though she never really moves past her love for the Isaac M. Singer . Meanwhile , Hayes prompt on with his beloved life history and never hit out to Solène again . SinceThe Idea of Youisn’t Harry Styles fanfiction , the book ’s ending palpate more realistic . Interestingly , the film take aim a much more distinctive fixed storage - com approach — not just to the ending , but to the couple ’s whole relationship .
Both The Book & Movie Missed Out On The Perfect Idea Of You Ending
An Ambiguous Ending Would Have Served Solène’s Story Better
As manifest byHayes ' watch inThe Idea of You , metre is an important composition in the celluloid . However , it ’s also true that time does n’t mend all wounds . Although Hayes and Solène ’s separation is amicable , their love affair did n’t need to be treated as an epic honey story . More than anything , The Idea of Youis a 2nd come - of - age for Solène — a woman who never really get the chance to let out herself outside of her union . Solène ’s love liaison with Hayes enables that self - discovery and geographic expedition , making their dearest important to Solène ’s larger story .
[ Solène ’s relationship with Hayes ] is something she care for that ’s made all - the - more precious because of its transitory caliber …
Still , that does n’t mean Solène and Hayes are an endgame couple . An ambiguous termination would have felt more square for many reason , but , perhaps most importantly , it would have preserved Solène ’s relationship with Hayes as this beautiful moment in prison term — something she cherishes that ’s made all - the - more precious because of its ephemeral caliber . Having Hayes ' say that he ’s headed to LA would have kept the door open for romantics , all while admit room for interpretation . Additionally , it would have keptThe Idea of You ’s ending focused on Solène , ensuring she was n’t yet again delimitate by her love life biography .
The Idea of Youis now streaming on Amazon Prime Video .
base on the acclaimed , modern-day love tarradiddle of the same name , The Idea of You centers on Solène ( Anne Hathaway ) , a 40 - year - erstwhile single mum who begins an unexpected romance with 24 - year - former Hayes Campbell ( Nicholas Galitzine ) , the atomic number 82 singer of August Moon , the hot boy band on the satellite . When Solène must tread in to chaperone her teen daughter ’s trip to the Coachella Music Festival after her ex bails at the last moment , she has a luck play with Hayes and there is an instant , undeniable electric discharge . As they begin a whirlwind romance , it is n’t long before Hayes ’ wizard status poses inescapable challenge to their human relationship , and Solène soon chance upon that life in the public eye of his spotlight might be more than she bargained for .
