Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
Summary
Since its release 25 age ago , Lucasfilm has rewrite the story ofStar war : Episode I - The Phantom Menaceand Anakin Skywalker himself . With the re - release ofThe Phantom Menacein theater , many have had the rare opportunity to revisit the firstchronological plastic film inStar Warsthe manner it was intend . block off the 3D re - release of the movie in 2012 , the 25th day of remembrance ofEpisode Iis allowing fans to realize just how much thefranchise has commute sinceThe Phantom Menaceon the prominent screenland .
As many have come to bed , Star Wars : The Phantom Menace ’s endingadequately sets up the quietus of the Skywalker Saga . From prove Anakin as a Jedi Padawan to setting up Senator Palpatine as the nefarious Emperor , the groundwork of the subsequent eight chronological films is established inThe Phantom Menace . Although this remains true , the discourse of theStar Warsfranchise since 1999 has see the meaning ofThe Phantom Menace- and Anakin Skywalker ’s part spark - somewhat altered .
Star state of war : Episode I - The Phantom Menace is 25 old age old this year . So what did Screen Rant ’s Head of Star Wars Tom Bacon teach from the rewatch ?
George Lucas' Protégé Dave Filoni Revealed The Meaning Of Qui-Gon’s Death
Qui-Gon’s Death In The Duel Of The Fates Has Been Outlined By Dave Filoni In Recent Years
Since 2019 , Dave Filoni has become an built-in part ofStar Warsstorytelling . Filoni has been involved in the franchise since 2008 due to his work onStar Wars : The Clone Wars , yet the release ofThe Mandalorianhas only go steady Filoni benefit more storytelling opportunity of increasing scale . This has led to Filoni being named as the author - director of an upcomingStar Warsmovie which is set to conclude the events of the New Republic timeline establish byThe Mandalorian , Ahsoka , and other television shows .
Through Filoni ’s increased involvement inStar Wars , the protégé of George Lucas has been able to adumbrate his own perception of the prequel trilogy . One scene that has received a sight of tending from Filoni is the Duel of the Fates fromStar Wars : The Phantom Menace ’s finale . InThe Mandalorian ’s Disney+ docudrama , Filoni was shown limn his view of the Duel of the Fates , and what the outcome of Qui - Gon ’s death meant for the dealership .
Qui - Gon know that Anakin is the choose One of the Force and needs someone open to emotion to guide him , something the other members of the Jedi Order do not body forth as openly .
Custom Image by Debanjana Chowdhury
Filoni explains thatthe reason the Duel of the Fates resonates so much with him is that it is a duel for the fate of Anakin Skywalker . Filoni state that Qui - Gon , knowing that the Jedi have lost touch with the galaxy and should be more open to pity , love , and spirit , is push to be the father figure Anakin demand . Qui - Gon knows that Anakin is the prefer One of the Force and needs someone assailable to emotion to guide him , something the other penis of the Jedi Order do not embody as openly .
In Filoni ’s opinion , when Qui - Gon dies , Anakin ’s fall to the dark side is all but confirm . After Qui - Gon ’s death , Anakin is handed off to Obi - Wan Kenobi . While Kenobi trains Anakin well and get along to roll in the hay him , he look at him as a brother rather than a boy . This cement Anakin ’s bend , and - in Filoni ’s view - is why the aptly style Duel of the Fates from the ending ofThe Phantom Menaceis so important .
John Williams has hidden many character reference to other stuff in his musical works , but his Duel of the Fates divine guidance is particularly ingenious .
Custom Image by Kevin Erdmann
This Wasn’t George Lucas' Interpretation Of The Phantom Menace
Lucas Saw Qui-Gon & Anakin’s Relationship In The Phantom Menace Differently
Interestingly , Filoni ’s - and thus Disney ’s - view of whatThe Phantom Menacemeans is middling unlike from George Lucas ' reading . Despite Filoni instruct a plenty from George Lucas , the latter once explore the idea that Qui - Gon was unseasonable for wish to train Anakin inThe Phantom Menace .
In an interview with Cut Magazine from 1999 ( viaDavid Talks SWon Tumblr ) , Lucas excuse his view of Qui - Gon and Anakin ’s human relationship :
" I think it is obvious that he [ Qui - Gon ] was incorrect in Episode I and made a severe decision , but in the end this decision may be correct . The ' phantom menace ' refers to the power of the dark side of the existence . Anakin will be taken over by dark forces which in turn ruin the balance of the Galaxy , but the soul who kills the Emperor is Darth Vader - also Anakin . "
Custom Image by Kevin Erdmann
Although Lucas acknowledges that Qui - Gon ’s decisiveness finally turn out right inReturn of the Jedi , he insists that Qui - Gon was patently haywire inThe Phantom Menace . In Lucas ' mind , Anakin Skywalker should never have been a Jedi in the first seat . If Lucas thinks Qui - Gon was wrong to insist on train Anakin , it mean the latter should have stay a striver on Tatooine to stave off the dangerous result of the Skywalker Saga .
Modern Star Wars Has Reinterpreted The Phantom Menace
Lucas' Original View Of Episode I Has Been Altered
As unmistakable , it is reset the rendition has changed since its release in 1999 . The conflict in point of view between Filoni and Lucas is quite staggering when localize in contrast with one another . Filoni ’s purview is exonerated that Qui - Gon Jinn was the hero that Anakin needed inThe Phantom Menace . This view implies that Qui - Gon was completely right in fighting for Anakin and that he was the only one in the Jedi Order who assure the truth;Anakin not having a father inStar Warsmeant he take a loving , like father public figure to prevent his conversion into Darth Vader .
Filoni ’s interpreting linkup to the modern Star Wars idea that the Jedi Order as a whole was flawed and that Qui - Gon ’s way was correct .
While Lucas likely also tally with this approximation , his vantage point has some utter opposites . Through the one comment that Qui - Gon Jinn was obviously incorrect in rail Anakin , Lucas views the former as a foolhardy Jedi who may have been too much like Anakin . In bringing Anakin into the folding of Jedi , Sith , and the Force , Qui - Gon dangerously placed the child onto the route to becoming Darth Vader . It may well be the case that Lucas is right and Anakin was never supposed to be a Jedi , as evidenced by the Will of the Force conceiving of him outside the Republic .
The Truth Will Always Depend On Your Point Of View
Interpretations Of The Skywalker Saga Will Always Depend On Singular Points Of View
Despite Filoni and Lucas have a different interpretation ofThe Phantom Menace , both have valid viewpoint . As is the case with anything regardingStar Wars -or cinematic - storytelling , the picture show will forever and a day be subject to subjective opinion . Neither Lucas nor Filoni are incorrect in their views ofThe Phantom Menace , just as neither of them is undoubtedly right . In realism , the truth of whatThe Phantom Menacemeans for the character of Anakin will always look on any individual spectator ’s percentage point of view .
Either viewpoint is valid and does not detract from the overall Skywalker Saga at large , as either could fit with the keep up eight movies .
While some may watchThe Phantom Menaceand think of Qui - Gon as a peculiar Jedi who was right in his view of Anakin , others could think he was reckless and endangered the intact galaxy . Either viewpoint is valid and does not detract from the overall Skywalker Saga at large , as either could fit with the follow eight movies . This truly highlights the lulu of a franchise likeStar Wars , a beauty that start out withStar Wars : Episode I - The Phantom Menacechronologically , as it is opened to any reading of its wide - reaching thematic geographic expedition .
Custom Image by Yailin Chacon
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
Star Wars : Episode I - The Phantom Menace is set in a galax facing political turmoil , as Jedi Knights Qui - Gon Jinn and Obi - Wan Kenobi search peace treaty while encountering Anakin Skywalker , a slave with corking potency in the Force . Meanwhile , the Sith begin their revival , threatening the constancy of the Republic .
